Manuscript Evaluation Form: Obituary

Article Title

1. Writing*

The writing is clear, objective, and concise. The separation of the text into sections and subsections is pertinent and facilitates the reading process.

2. Coverage*

The manuscript covers the entire work of the author in question.

3. Memory*

The recall of the author's memory is cohesive and linear, clearly highlighting the author's main contributions to the field of research.

4. Connections and developments*

The manuscript contributes to demonstrating the impact of the author's scientific legacy and its potential developments and impacts on related field themes.

5. General Evaluation*

Please provide a qualitative assessment of the manuscript in the space below. It is recommended that comments be provided on each of the items evaluated above, and that they be as clear and specific as possible. This space is also intended for general comments that could lead to an improvement in the manuscript. Such comments may pertain to the structure of the manuscript (division of sections/subsections) or other useful comments for the authors.

6. Reviewer Conclusion* 


7. In compliance with Open Science, we ask if you (reviewer) agree with the publication of the manuscript evaluation reports, according to the following options:*